I’m Reminded Of A Saying About Lawyers…
Something along the lines of a lawyer who represents himself has a fool for a client.
John Edgar Wideman sounds like he’s fed up with self-publishing and will publish his new collection of short stories with print-on-demand service Lulu.com.
It must sound appealing; throwing off the shackles of a stifling publishing program to go it alone. However, one must never confuse printing with publishing.
Whether or not Wideman thinks his publisher (Houghton Mifflin) gave due diligence to his books, setting up shop with a print-on-demand company puts him among other authors whose only requirement is that they pony up the cash required.
I’m not saying that New York publishing is the most reliable gatekeeper, or even that gatekeepers are required, it’s just that while print-on-demand may sound like a sweet deal for all concerned, it usually means a raw deal for booksellers. Bookstores cannot order Lulu.com books the same way they would order a book from a regular publisher: discounts tend to stink, invoicing is non-existent (usually these companies are pre-paid only) and books are non-returnable.
It just seems to me that Wideman is trading one publishing ghetto (that of the marginalized midlist author) for another.


